星空传媒

Politics

    • We asked an economist if the capital gains tax changes will really generate nearly $20B

    Share

    The Liberals' proposed changes to the capital gains tax passed in the House of Commons on Tuesday, clearing the way for the federal government to hike the amount of tax Canadians pay on the sale of assets or investments.

    The changes, which come into effect June 25, will raise the inclusion rate on capital gains to 67 per cent for Canadians earning more than $250,000 through stocks or secondary properties, up from the current 50 per cent.

    Since it was first brought up in April, several business groups have criticized the proposals, including a joint letter from the Canadian Chamber of Commerce, the Canadian Federation of Independent Business, Canadian Manufacturers and Exporters, and several other organizations.

    "This measure will limit opportunities for all generations and make Canada a less competitive, and less innovative nation," the letter said.

    To counter the pushback, Prime Minister Justin Trudeau released a video on social media May 13, explaining the changes will only affect "less than one per cent of people."

    "At a time when the richest are only getting richer, I think it's fair to ask those people to pay a little more," Trudeau said in the video. He also claimed that the changes "will result in almost $20 billion in new revenue" 鈥 $19.7 billion over five years, to be exact 鈥 that will go to investments in affordable housing.

    But how accurate are the government's claims? Would these proposed changes really provide that much new revenue for the feds? Will Canada's ultra-wealthy be the ones who pay their "fair share" through the new tax increase?

    Would the government really be able to generate $20B in tax revenue?

    Joseph Steinberg is an associate professor with the University of Toronto's economics department. With a PhD in economics, Steinberg's research uses quantitative models to study public finance and policy.

    Speaking with CTVNews.ca, he says these types of policies are unlikely to raise much in the way of tax revenue, and that it will be far less than the near $20 billion the government claims it could generate.

    "I don't think that this specific policy is likely to be successful," he said. "Suppose this policy is going to affect less than one per cent of Canadian households, or the very, very rich. The problem with this is they're precisely the same population of households that engage in offshore tax evasion and other forms of tax avoidance."

    Through years of research, Steinberg says bills and legislation similar to this only affect "moderately" rich Canadians 鈥 those we may consider to be upper-middle class, who own two cars, maybe own or share a cottage 鈥 not the ultra-wealthy that it's being promoted as targeting.

    Leader of the Liberal Party of Canada Justin Trudeau speaks during a Liberal Party of Canada fundraiser in Ottawa, on Monday, June 10, 2024. (Spencer Colby/The Canadian Press)

    "Imagine somebody who's got an investment property or a cottage. Maybe they won't sell it this year or next year, but they're going to sell it at some point in the future," he said. "If that sale goes beyond $250,000, that household is going to be affected. Very few Canadians annually earn more than a quarter-of-a-million dollars in capital gains, but the percentage of people who will at one point, that exceeds one per cent."

    Going one step further, Steinberg says the ultra-wealthy usually like this kind of policy, because "they have ways to avoid them."

    "If the goal (of the proposal) is to reduce inequality," he continued, "these kinds of policies aren't going to help."

    What could the government be doing instead?

    Steinberg says this type of proposal doesn't really attack one of the root causes of wealth inequality, which he says is tax avoidance.

    "Given what my research into policies on raising taxes on the wealthy has found 鈥 since we don't enforce any rules against tax avoidance and tax evasion, these kinds of policies are really unlikely to raise much, if any, in the way of tax revenues."

    The Canada loses nearly $3 billion a year in offshore investing, which is close to how much the government projects to bring in each year with the changes. Steinberg reiterates that's where the government could make the rich pay their fair share.

    "I would recommend, instead of this policy, ramp up enforcement of tax evasion by the ultra rich. Give the CRA even more resources to audit really rich households, more resources to fight money laundering," he said.

    "The return on that investment would be pretty high for the government."

    Pushback and praise for the proposals

    Others have criticized the proposals, including some in the tech sector. When Deputy Prime Minister and Finance Minister Chrystia Freeland introduced the motion to Parliament Monday, Shopify president Harley Finkelstein shared a critical post on X, calling the move "a tax on innovation and risk-taking."

    "Investing in new products or ideas is inherently risky. Entrepreneurs need incentives, not penalties, to drive (Canadians) forward," he wrote. "This policy will disincentivize risk-taking and tax Canadian ambition at a time when we need more entrepreneurs, not fewer."

    But while the Liberals hammer the point that the proposal targets the richest people in the country, Steinberg says it's impossible to ignore the amount of pushback it's received from those in various tax brackets.

    "I think it's fair to say that Trudeau and his government are pretty unpopular, and people are less likely to be inclined to view any kind of policy that his government proposes favourably," he said.

    Steinberg also says the rising costs of living and inflation are at the forefront of Canadians' minds, and that this proposal may not be something they perceive as helpful in their day-to-day lives.

    Not everyone thinks the policy would stifle innovation. Jon Shell is the chair of Social Capital Partners, a non-profit that focuses on rising wealth concentration. Through a , he argues that the capital gains tax in the '90s was 75 per cent. 

    "(The '90s) also happens to be the decade everyone says was best for productivity, growth, investment, whatever," he wrote. "All the productivity people LOVE the 1990s. Lowering the rate (to 50 per cent in October 2000) had no impact on productivity or investment, but was certainly great for the super rich, and certainly great for me when I sold my companies in 2020." 

    Several groups representing educators have also spoken in favour of the proposal, saying it could make a difference for future generations of Canadians.

    "The Canadian Teachers' Federation (CTF) is pleased to support changes that contribute to the federal government's ability to make investments that enhance the common good, such as a national school food program, child care, poverty alleviation and more," Cassandra Hallet, the executive director of the CTF .

    Karen Littlewood, president of the Ontario Secondary School Teachers' Federation, echoed the sentiment.

    "Asking for tax fairness is not a bad thing," . "Asking the wealthiest 0.13 per cent of Canadians to pay a little more so ALL Canadians can have pharmacare and dental and school nutrition programs is a good thing."

    IN DEPTH

    Opinion

    opinion

    opinion Don Martin: How a beer break may have doomed the carbon tax hike

    When the Liberal government chopped a planned beer excise tax hike to two per cent from 4.5 per cent and froze future increases until after the next election, says political columnist Don Martin, it almost guaranteed a similar carbon tax move in the offing.

    CTVNews.ca 星空传媒

    A B.C. judge has ordered the sale of a Surrey home despite the objections of the woman who lives there, who owns it jointly with her son.

    A landlord in Ottawa is facing thousands of dollars in repairs after his tenant left his only rental property damaged and disorderly.

    A woman has died and four others have been taken to hospital following a hit-and-run collision overnight on the Gardiner Expressway.

    As receipts tick ever higher for Canadians at the grocery store and shoppers continue to search for savings, one Canadian grocer has ended a perceived deal.

    Police in Cape Breton are investigating reports of a scam involving a seemingly stranded motorist flagging down drivers and offering gold jewelry in exchange for money to pay for gas or repairs.

    Canada

    • Ottawa city councillor Clarke Kelly says he is not apologizing after a Kinburn daycare owner alleged he screamed and swore in front of children during a dispute that saw police called to the scene on Wednesday afternoon.

    • A Calgary man is $66 million richer after claiming a Lotto 6-49 jackpot.

    • Waterloo, Ont., regional police have arrested a man in connection to a Canada Day firework incident involving a city councillor.

    • A woman has died and four others have been taken to hospital following a hit-and-run collision overnight on the Gardiner Expressway.

    • Lacey may look like just another pet chicken on Emily Carrington鈥檚 B.C. property. But she has a title her coop mates don鈥檛: Guinness World Record holder.

    World

    Politics

    Health

    Sci-Tech

    Entertainment

    Business

    Lifestyle

    Sports

    Autos

    Local Spotlight

    Lacey may look like just another pet chicken on Emily Carrington鈥檚 B.C. property. But she has a title her coop mates don鈥檛: Guinness World Record holder.

    Philip Kim, who competes as "B-Boy Phil Wizard," is set to make Canadian sports history this summer as the country's first-ever Olympic breaking athlete.

    A new documentary filmed in Nova Scotia by marine biologist and veterinarian Dr. Chris Harvey Clark explores the increased number of white shark observations in Canadian waters.

    A never-before-lived-in mansion in Whistler is on the market for $17.9 million 鈥 with the listing describing it as a 'steal for the international buyer' due to the current exchange rate, which puts the price in U.S. dollars at $13.1 million.

    Irish singer Niall Horan had to ditch his car and walk to Scotiabank Arena where his concert was being held last weekend because the traffic was 'too bad' downtown.

    A rave at the Ontario Science Centre was the place where Greg LeBlanc says his relationship first began with his husband Mark in 1997.

    The city is entering the final stages of resuming water service through its repaired feeder main, as water consumption continues to fall below the city鈥檚 threshold level.

    • Chef Gus Stieffenhofer-Brandson says that when it comes to a fat B.C. peach, there are "endless possibilities" for a fruit that signifies summer.

    • A pedestrian pilot project is now open in one of Vancouver鈥檚 liveliest neighbourhoods.

    • A key defensive weapon for the B.C. Lions has had his season cut short by a knee injury.

    • Ontarians could see long lineups at LCBO stores across the province today as customers prepare for a possible strike that will close all LCBO locations for the next two weeks.

    • An Ontario woman said she was freaking out when she found a venomous black widow spider in a bag of grapes her husband had bought at Walmart earlier that day.

    • A woman has died and four others have been taken to hospital following a hit-and-run collision overnight on the Gardiner Expressway.

    • Fueling Minds, the company at the centre of an E. coli outbreak last year, is dealing with another infection.

    • Alberta Occupational Health and Safety (OHS) has filed 10 charges against a Brooks-based water management agency in connection with the death of a diver in 2022.

    • As the Greatest Outdoor Show on Earth gets ready to welcome thousands of visitors, Calgary Stampede events are kicking off around the city.

    • As receipts tick ever higher for Canadians at the grocery store and shoppers continue to search for savings, one Canadian grocer has ended a perceived deal.

    • Ottawa city councillor Clarke Kelly says he is not apologizing after a Kinburn daycare owner alleged he screamed and swore in front of children during a dispute that saw police called to the scene on Wednesday afternoon.

    • A landlord in Ottawa is facing thousands of dollars in repairs after his tenant left his only rental property damaged and disorderly.

    • Ireland's prime minister says he's "absolutely appalled" by an assault in the country's capital that resulted in the death of a tourist from Montreal.

    • In Jamaica, people were shopping for essentials and fishermen were bringing boats back to shore as they braced for the worst ahead of Hurricane Beryl.

    • The number of disciplinary cases against Quebec realtors accused of "financially abusing" their clients is going up.

    • Here's a look at some of the wild weather from around the world this past week.

    • The RCMP are searching for a man they say asked two 15-year-old girls if they wanted to have sex with him and punched a 14-year-boy in St. Albert last Wednesday.

    • Photos posted online Thursday morning appear to show a dead humpback whale in Nova Scotia鈥檚 Shubenacadie River.

    • The government of Canada and Prince Edward Island's Mi'kmaq First Nations announced an agreement on Thursday to turn a pristine chain of islands with sacred cultural significance into a national park reserve.

    • The Halifax Regional Municipality is advising residents to avoid swimming at two Dartmouth, N.S., beaches due to high bacteria levels in the water.

    • One school division in Manitoba is banning cellphones from the classroom.

    • Assiniboine Park officials are reminding the public to be vigilant around coyotes, amid reports the canines have been getting a bit too comfortable interacting with the public.

    • Winnipeggers will soon be able to pair their taquitos and Big Bite hot dogs with a glass of red.

    • School divisions across Saskatchewan are making it known that fiscal challenges remain, despite the province's attempts at addressing capacity issues in its most recent budget.

    • A Regina couple who were paid $800 in compensation from Sunwing Airlines are now being taken back to court as the airline seeks to overturn the decision.

    • Regina police have identified 29-year-old Skylar Ochuschayoo as a suspect in the city's third homicide of the year.

    • Mark McCreadie鈥檚 family fears his admitted killer will harm someone else if he鈥檚 ever released from prison.

    • Waterloo, Ont., regional police have arrested a man in connection to a Canada Day firework incident involving a city councillor.

    • OpenText Corp.'s chief executive says the company plans to shed about 1,200 roles as part of a business optimization plan.

    • Shoppers who frequent Co-op stores in Saskatoon and the area may have to shop around to get what they need because of limited supply due to a cyberattack.

    • Traffic restrictions are in place for Northbound traffic exiting from Highway 16 onto Circle Drive East due to a single-vehicle collision involving a school bus.

    • The mother of a Saskatoon homicide victim says getting justice in her daughter鈥檚 killing has been painful.

    • A 33-year-old man has been charged with attempted murder after a victim was attacked with a blunt object Wednesday evening in downtown Sudbury.

    • A northern Ontario beekeeper has lost half of her bee population 鈥 more than 1.5 million bees to be exact 鈥 due to what she believes is an acute chemical kill.

    • The driver of a commercial motor vehicle has been charged after police noticed something dangling underneath the vehicle.

    • A youth has been charged with first degree murder after emergency services responded to a Cut Line Road address between Parr Line and Tipperary Line in Central Huron, where another youth was found, taken to hospital, and later pronounced deceased.

    • Pro-Palestinian protestors on Western University鈥檚 campus held a rally Wednesday night, saying they aren鈥檛 going anywhere.

    • The province's Special Investigations Unit is investigating a fatal crash in Springwater Township.

    • Ontario Provincial Police laid almost 18,000 charges between June 21 and July 1.

    • Police arrested and charged two individuals for allegedly stealing over $5,000 worth of furniture from an Airbnb.

    • The former Sears building in Devonshire Mall is set to be torn down later this month.

    • Ontarians could see long lineups at LCBO stores across the province today as customers prepare for a possible strike that will close all LCBO locations for the next two weeks.

    • A Maidstone couple discovers an unexpected object while doing landscaping in their backyard.

    • Chef Gus Stieffenhofer-Brandson says that when it comes to a fat B.C. peach, there are "endless possibilities" for a fruit that signifies summer.

    • Five earthquakes were recorded in quick succession off the British Columbia coast on Wednesday afternoon.

    • As Hurricane Beryl churns through the Caribbean, levelling coastal communities, Global Affairs Canada has issued a travel advisory for areas already devastated 鈥 and those in the path of the storm.

    • British Columbia residents are being told to brace for a coming heat wave that could send temperatures into the high 30s and beyond, with the government reminding people to check in on their neighbours.

    • A swath of B.C.鈥檚 southern Interior is being told to brace for potential severe thunderstorms Tuesday.

    • A severe thunderstorm watch is in effect Sunday for a swath of the B.C. Interior, according to Environment and Climate Change Canada.

    • One of two men accused of conspiring to kill Mounties at the border blockade at Coutts, Alta., characterized the protest as a last stand and told his mother there 鈥渨ill be a war鈥 if police moved in.

    • With the recent moisture and cooler temperatures, fire bans and restrictions in the Lethbridge area are no longer in effect.

    • Plenty of tourists will descend on Lethbridge to see what the city offers. Locals, too, will have no shortage of activities this weekend.

    • Sault Ste. Marie native and four-time Stanley Cup champion Marty Pavelich has died.

    • Police and city officials say a Pride display in Sault Ste. Marie, Ont., was vandalized.

    • A federal court hearing Wednesday saw lawyers for Elliot Lake homeowners and the Attorney General of Canada argue over the definition of nuclear mine waste.

    N.L.

    Stay Connected
    Follow CTV News